{
  "id": "release-gate-integrity",
  "name": "release-gate-integrity",
  "title": "部署门禁完整性与候选验收回执",
  "description": "浏览器缓存复制12/12及独立复核通过，按授权本地提交最终候选；待一次正确复制、双引擎先验及原完整门禁。无推送部署授权。",
  "status": "in_progress",
  "dev_type": null,
  "scope": "release-gate",
  "package": null,
  "priority": "P1",
  "creator": "shunli",
  "assignee": "shunli",
  "createdAt": "2026-09-06",
  "completedAt": null,
  "branch": "codex/20260919-reviewed-candidate",
  "base_branch": "main",
  "worktree_path": null,
  "commit": null,
  "pr_url": null,
  "subtasks": [],
  "children": [],
  "parent": null,
  "relatedFiles": [],
  "notes": "2026-09-19 R1定向125通过、另外两份46通过、生命周期52补充通过；原组2 exit1及3次超时保留，新增require不在其执行片段内。六项代码独立复核PASS，无理由合并保护或增预算。允许本地提交，最终完整门禁尚未执行；不具备发布资格。\n2026-09-19 根据用户对重复全浏览器成本的反馈，中止budget-full-r1；后端4446与PG28通过保留，浏览器29通过/4中断/339未运行，回执FAIL/130，环境清理PASS。待Claude实际补丁复核，发布完整门禁延期，不再重跑无关测试。\n2026-09-19 预算并发修复已定向通过 PG28/单测526；待新完整候选与独立审查，旧r6为历史输入。\n2026-09-19 用户独立核实确认4437/r6时序及累计diff基线，并报告当前采购测试75 passed/EXIT=0、SHA一致；数量与证据归属争议闭合。完整独立业务review、发布边界及两条例外保持。\n2026-09-19 用户转述局部审查已核对：UTC/北京时间混用及累计diff误作运行后diff；r6实际在P10之后，4437准确，1162源码快照条目与当前一致。证据review-provenance-20260919.json，完整独立review仍PENDING，原证据不改。\n2026-09-19 g20-full-r6：4437后端通过/1原跳过，372本地浏览器全过；PARTIAL仅dirty_candidate，独立PENDING/无部署，旧registry保护例外保留且无新增漂移。当前余额见implement顶部。\n2026-09-18 G19分层验收已批准并本地实施验证，74+7合成检查和2条冻结保护通过；公网12义务/完整门禁/WebKit/R1/独立及真实事实保持开放。\n2026-09-18 G18：QA39、产品131、并发4/4、认证/OCR18/18，33路由项与R108通过；G18时点发现64/363；G19最新发现见g19-discovery/summary.json，旧完整full-r2仍失败。候选与余项见local-coverage-g18-20260918。无提交部署，独立PENDING。\n2026-09-18 G16/G17：普通 full-r2 65/359仍失败；14原失败及2串行缺失已有定向通过，1WebKit/2冻结差旅保留。当前发现64/358，有临时SHA采集告警；QA/治理/保护与增量候选见 full-gates-followup-20260918。整体in_progress、独立PENDING，六组余项见implement顶部，无提交部署/外部操作。\n2026-09-18 G12/G13本地收口，G14真实PWA通过但WebKit1条未验；原58现53重验/4排除/1未验，原历史不改。G15复核及外部事实清单与新候选在retained-gates-closeout-20260917；普通full-local/AC7完整/R1和独立PENDING，不提交部署或真实操作。\n2026-09-17 W8本地对账：四处迁移状态谓词修复已随b87cc55发布；该事实仅闭合追加预检阶段，不代表R1普通完整门禁、阶段B合同用例或58条诊断观测已通过。R1/阶段B继续原冻结，先按保留在用场景分类再另定限定批次，不盲修待精简旧测试。 原回执从主副本接回，见implement顶部；本轮无新的远端/提交发布，原验收未补勾。\n2026-09-07 §10已实施并完成一次环境有效的全套诊断，增量待用户独立复核。原21文件加6个QA环境/测试文件，共27文件；本轮产品源码和业务spec零改动，51项针对性验证通过。前三次启动在环境前置拒绝，资源已核对清理；修复跨user namespace读取父namespace的EACCES，改由父runner经本轮Unix IPC即时实测，不降级。第四次环境PASS、源码前后不变：65文件275项，199 passed/54 failed/4 timedOut/18 skipped，58条观测涉及36文件，不是独立产品缺陷计数；诊断仍PARTIAL/2。服务端193文件1692项通过，workflow场景8两个来源仍失败。R102 6/6通过；合同仍卡旧更多，续约/归档未执行；PWA在serviceWorker.ready超时且该失败无trace附件。诊断67分03秒不是普通全绿成本。旧207撤销决策资格但保留原件；阶段1、阶段B、场景8、经理缺口和R1均未扩大执行。无提交/push/归档/部署/生产操作，整体任务未完成。",
  "meta": {
    "archiveOutputProtection": "implemented_pending_independent_review",
    "registeredLocalEvidenceVerified": 14,
    "runtimeScreenshotsPreserved": 4,
    "targetedQaTestsPassed": 64,
    "fullDiagnosticRerun": false,
    "g16g17": {
      "ordinaryFullResult": "FAIL",
      "originalBrowserCases": 359,
      "focusedRevalidatedOriginalFailures": 14,
      "revalidatedSerialOmissions": 2,
      "currentDiscoveredCases": 358,
      "independentReview": "PENDING",
      "normalReleaseEligible": false
    },
    "g18": {
      "currentDiscoveredCases": 363,
      "currentDiscoveredSpecs": 64,
      "concurrentGroupPassed": 4,
      "authOcrPassed": 18,
      "ordinaryFullResult": "FAIL",
      "independentReview": "PENDING",
      "normalReleaseEligible": false
    },
    "g19": {
      "state": "LOCAL_VERIFIED_PUBLIC_PENDING",
      "discovered": 365,
      "localMandatory": 351,
      "publicMandatory": 12,
      "frozenRetained": 2,
      "coverageTests": 74,
      "freezeProtectionPassed": 2,
      "independentReview": "PENDING",
      "normalReleaseEligible": false
    },
    "latestLocalCandidate": {
      "run": "g20-full-r6",
      "localChecksPassed": true,
      "receiptStatus": "PARTIAL",
      "browserPassed": 372,
      "publicPending": 12,
      "independentReview": "PARTIAL_WITH_BLOCKING_FINDING",
      "deploymentEligible": false,
      "legacyProtectionStatus": "FAIL_ONE_KNOWN_DERIVED_REGISTRY",
      "newProtectedDrift": false,
      "productionNumberingActivated": false
    },
    "reviewProvenanceReconciliation": {
      "status": "CONFIRMED_BY_USER_INDEPENDENT_CHECK",
      "evidence": "artifacts/qa-layout/submit-visual-closeout-20260918/review-provenance-20260919.json",
      "r6BackendPassed": 4437,
      "earlierBackendPassed": 4428,
      "currentSourceDigestMatchesR6": true,
      "independentReview": "PROVENANCE_CONFIRMED_FULL_BUSINESS_REVIEW_PENDING",
      "deploymentEligible": false,
      "confirmedScope": [
        "test counts",
        "UTC and Asia/Shanghai chronology",
        "incremental diff baseline",
        "release eligibility boundary",
        "retained exceptions"
      ],
      "reportedFocusedRetest": {
        "source": "user-provided independent verification",
        "file": "server/tests/unit/routes/purchase-request.errors.test.js",
        "passed": 75,
        "exitCode": 0,
        "sha256Prefix": "2b9ec41d",
        "rawLogInspectedByMainSession": false
      },
      "countAndProvenanceDispute": "CLOSED"
    },
    "claudeBusinessReview20260919": {
      "status": "PARTIAL",
      "source": "user_provided_claude_report",
      "rawReviewerLogsObtained": false,
      "blockingFindingsReported": 0,
      "pending": [
        "feeControl budget/expense-standard semantics",
        "reimbursements concurrency/transaction paths",
        "K0 contract and local coverage",
        "remaining consumers/pages/migrations after targeted coverage check"
      ],
      "evidence": "artifacts/qa-governance/trellis-0617-review-followup-20260919",
      "deploymentEligible": false
    },
    "claudeBusinessFollowup20260919": {
      "status": "PARTIAL_WITH_BLOCKING_FINDING",
      "reviewerTask": "b1rubx7qf",
      "report": "artifacts/qa-governance/business-followup-claude-review-20260919T023537Z.txt",
      "reportSha256": "b48e5f53340e139e5a97b5fdcb6d7003881a80a8a08d4004d01aaa6a759d2d0b",
      "reviewerExecution": "STATIC_SOURCE_AND_EXISTING_TEST_REVIEW_ONLY",
      "feeControlP9": "PASS_SCOPED",
      "reimbursementLocksAndRecheck": "PASS_SCOPED",
      "budgetPoolConcurrency": "FAIL_CONFIRMED_STATIC",
      "findingId": "BUDGET-LOST-UPDATE-01",
      "remediationStatus": "LOCAL_VERIFIED_INDEPENDENT_REVIEWED",
      "remediationTask": ".trellis/tasks/09-19-budget-pool-concurrency",
      "k0Contract": "PASS_STATIC_CONTENT_REVIEW",
      "k0Observations": "BOUNDARIES_CLARIFIED_NOT_RUNTIME_VERIFIED",
      "remainingCoverage": [
        "workflow snapshot internals",
        "withdraw/pay/link-project business branches beyond lock presence",
        "remaining crypto consumers as applicable"
      ],
      "evidence": "artifacts/qa-governance/business-followup-reception-20260919",
      "deploymentEligible": false,
      "remediationReviewResult": "artifacts/qa-governance/budget-pool-concurrency-20260919/review-fixes-20260919/claude-result-20260919T044304Z.md"
    },
    "budgetPoolPatchCandidate": {
      "task": ".trellis/tasks/09-19-budget-pool-concurrency",
      "run": "budget-full-r1",
      "status": "INTERRUPTED_NOT_PASS",
      "targetedPostgresPassed": 28,
      "targetedUnitPassed": 526,
      "independentReview": "PASS_SCOPED_BUDGET_PATCH",
      "deploymentEligible": false,
      "backendTestsPassed": 4446,
      "backendFilesPassed": 225,
      "localChecksPassed": false,
      "releaseFullGate": "DEFERRED_UNTIL_RELEASE_PREPARATION",
      "interruption": "User objected to repeated full browser testing; remaining run stopped and owned environment cleaned.",
      "followupEvidence": "artifacts/qa-governance/budget-pool-concurrency-20260919/review-fixes-20260919",
      "reviewFixTestsPassed": 928,
      "requiredReviewFindingsOpen": 0,
      "remediationStatus": "LOCAL_VERIFIED_INDEPENDENT_REVIEWED"
    },
    "releasePreparation": {
      "status": "LOCAL_COMMITS_COMPLETE_R1_PLAN_READY",
      "executor": "main Codex session",
      "request": "artifacts/qa-governance/release-preparation-claude-request-20260919.md",
      "scope": "read-only candidate inventory and actionable release preparation",
      "testsAuthorizedInThisStep": false,
      "commitPushDeploymentAuthorized": false,
      "report": "artifacts/qa-governance/release-preparation-claude-20260919T050016Z.md",
      "reportSha256": "42fffaf6bc7f81e45bf959eed7a24acb0a773f05fd97cb473a0c5e49273b49e5",
      "nextRequest": "artifacts/qa-governance/release-commit-packaging-claude-request-20260919.md",
      "plannedCommitCount": 2,
      "jsonlDecision": "INCLUDE_REAL_CONTEXT_ENTRIES",
      "pythonFixtureDecision": "INCLUDE_TEST_ONLY_STDLIB_DEPENDENCY",
      "localCommitAuthorized": true,
      "pushAuthorized": false,
      "deploymentAuthorized": false,
      "r1ActivationAuthorized": false,
      "priorClaudePackagingRequest": "SUPERSEDED_BY_USER_REQUEST",
      "commitEvidence": "artifacts/qa-governance/local-commits-20260919",
      "firstLocalCommit": "729d90576f25ba658656508af1af32a179aa7057",
      "commitResultReceipt": "artifacts/qa-governance/local-commits-20260919/result.json"
    },
    "r1IntegrationPlan": {
      "status": "FINAL_GATE_FAIL_NATIVE_PROBE_DIAGNOSTIC_PENDING",
      "planningApproved": true,
      "implementationApproved": true,
      "enforcementEnabled": true,
      "baselineCommit": "1f8d5b658a9fcae15be192af8c82ab557f88a046",
      "designSection": "R1 接入方案（2026-09-19，已批准本地实施）",
      "executionFiles": [
        "scripts/qa/release-gate-result.mjs",
        "scripts/qa/run-release-gate.sh",
        "deploy/trialrun/production-identity-bootstrap.mjs",
        "deploy/trialrun/deploy-existing.sh",
        "deploy/trialrun/deploy.sh"
      ],
      "testExecutor": "Claude independent session",
      "testsRun": true,
      "pushAuthorized": false,
      "deploymentAuthorized": false,
      "approval": "用户确认本地R1接入与先实施再最终一次完整门禁的顺序；不含推送或部署",
      "enforcementScope": "local committed code; no real deployment executed",
      "localEnforcementImplemented": true,
      "testStatus": "SCOPED_PASS_WITH_RECORDED_PRIOR_TIMEOUT",
      "independentReview": "PASS_6_POINTS_CAUSE_CORRECTION_RECEIVED",
      "deploymentEligible": false,
      "evidenceDirectory": "artifacts/qa-governance/r1-enforcement-20260919",
      "handoff": "artifacts/qa-governance/r1-enforcement-20260919/claude-request.md",
      "reviewReception": "artifacts/qa-governance/r1-enforcement-20260919/review-reception.json",
      "nextHandoff": "artifacts/qa-governance/r1-enforcement-20260919/native-probe-20260919/claude-request.md",
      "f1": {
        "discoveryStatus": "THREE_TIMEOUTS_CONFIRMED",
        "attribution": "R1_DIRECT_CAUSE_DISPROVED",
        "remediationStatus": "NO_CODE_FIX_INDICATED_SCOPED_REVALIDATION_PASS",
        "historicalRootCause": "UNDETERMINED",
        "supplementalRun": {
          "tests": 52,
          "passed": 52,
          "exitCode": 0,
          "budgetMs": 5000
        },
        "productionChecksPreserved": true
      },
      "diagnosticReception": "artifacts/qa-governance/r1-enforcement-20260919/f1-triage-20260919/diagnostic-reception.json",
      "localCommitEvidence": "artifacts/qa-governance/r1-enforcement-20260919/local-commit/result.json",
      "localCommit": "16b9cad98c4687b8328a69a47f192077f0c63dab",
      "finalGateAttempt": {
        "candidate": "16b9cad98c4687b8328a69a47f192077f0c63dab",
        "run": "r1-final-gate-llu75eza",
        "exitCode": 1,
        "static": "PASS",
        "fullLocal": "ENVIRONMENT_INVALID",
        "internalStagesRun": 0,
        "deploymentEligible": false
      }
    },
    "nativeProbeRepair": {
      "status": "COMMITTED_SCOPED_VERIFIED",
      "failureReception": "artifacts/qa-governance/r1-enforcement-20260919/native-probe-20260919/failure-reception.json",
      "historicalGateStatus": "FAIL",
      "fullLocalStagesRun": 0,
      "rootCause": "UNDETERMINED",
      "testExecutor": "Claude independent session",
      "deploymentEligible": false,
      "testsRunByMainSession": false,
      "actualRootCauseResolved": false,
      "handoff": "artifacts/qa-governance/r1-enforcement-20260919/native-probe-20260919/webkit-comparison-20260919/claude-request.md",
      "environmentDifferences": [
        "private HOME/XDG/TMPDIR",
        "fresh copy of failed cache",
        "no database or managed receipt"
      ],
      "independentReview": "PASS",
      "unit": {
        "tests": 37,
        "passed": 36,
        "failed": 1,
        "skipped": 0,
        "exitCode": 1
      },
      "ipcFailure": "MISSING_SOCKET_ASSERTION_LINE_80",
      "ipcHypothesis": "LONG_TMPDIR_SOCKET_ALIASING_NOT_RUNTIME_CONFIRMED",
      "diagnostic": "FAIL_WEBKIT_PAGE_PROCESS_CLOSED",
      "reviewReception": "artifacts/qa-governance/r1-enforcement-20260919/native-probe-20260919/webkit-comparison-20260919/review-reception.json",
      "validationByFile": {
        "probePriorPassed": 30,
        "environmentSupplementalPassed": 7,
        "singleRun37Pass": false
      },
      "localCommit": "6e57d337157753efb8eb82a1dd725ffa33544f1a"
    },
    "webkitComparison": {
      "status": "COMPLETE_A_FAIL_B_FAIL_C_PASS",
      "cases": [
        "deep-materialized",
        "short-materialized",
        "short-internal-links"
      ],
      "maxAttemptsPerCase": 1,
      "deploymentEligible": false,
      "caseExits": [
        1,
        1,
        0
      ],
      "conclusion": "INTERNAL_LINK_STRUCTURE_RELATED",
      "historyUniqueRootCauseProven": false
    },
    "browserCacheCopy": {
      "status": "SCOPED_VERIFIED_LOCAL_COMMIT_AND_FINAL_GATE_HANDOFF",
      "evidence": "artifacts/qa-governance/r1-enforcement-20260919/cache-copy-20260919",
      "testExecutor": "Claude",
      "fullGateStarted": false,
      "deploymentEligible": false,
      "executionFile": "scripts/qa/copy-browser-cache.py",
      "testFile": "scripts/qa/tests/browser-cache-copy.test.mjs",
      "handoff": "artifacts/qa-governance/r1-enforcement-20260919/cache-copy-20260919/claude-request.md",
      "testsRunByCodex": false,
      "testResult": {
        "passed": 12,
        "failed": 0,
        "skipped": 0,
        "exitCode": 0
      },
      "independentReview": "PASS",
      "reception": "artifacts/qa-governance/r1-enforcement-20260919/cache-copy-20260919/final-candidate/review-reception.json",
      "nextHandoff": "artifacts/qa-governance/r1-enforcement-20260919/cache-copy-20260919/final-candidate/claude-request.md",
      "localCommitReceipt": "artifacts/qa-governance/r1-enforcement-20260919/cache-copy-20260919/final-candidate/local-commit.json"
    },
    "finalLinkedCacheGate": {
      "status": "PLANNED_NOT_RUN",
      "copyAndNativePreflight": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_ORIGINAL_FULL_GATE",
      "maxCompleteAttempts": 1,
      "maxNativePreflightAttempts": 1,
      "pushAuthorized": false,
      "deploymentAuthorized": false,
      "deploymentEligible": false
    }
  }
}